Resource Guide
Getting Medical Treatment After a Construction Accident — What Workers Need to Know
Where you go for treatment, which doctors you see, and how consistent your care is will all affect your case. Here's how to protect both your health and your claim.
Go to the Hospital You Choose — Not the One Your Employer Picks
After a construction accident, your employer or site supervisor may direct you to a specific clinic, urgent care center, or occupational health provider. They have a reason for that: those facilities often have relationships with the workers' comp carrier and may produce conservative evaluations that minimize your injuries.
You have the right to go to any emergency room or hospital. For a serious accident — a fall, crush injury, head trauma, fracture — go to the ER. Don't let your employer steer you to their preferred clinic if you have a serious injury. The care you receive there and the records generated will follow your case for years.
Workers' Comp Doctor vs. Your Own Doctor
Under workers' comp in New York, you're generally required to treat with authorized workers' comp providers for your comp benefits. That's separate from your personal injury case.
For your personal injury lawsuit, your own treating physicians — specialists you choose independently — carry far more weight. A workers' comp doctor selected by the carrier will often give minimal opinions on your injuries. Seeing an orthopedist, neurologist, or neurosurgeon on your own creates medical records and expert opinions that your attorney can use to build your damages.
The Independent Medical Examination (IME) — What It Actually Is
The workers' comp carrier and defense attorneys will eventually require you to attend an Independent Medical Examination. The name is misleading: the examining doctor is hired and paid by the insurance company. The exam typically lasts 15–20 minutes. The report almost always minimizes your injuries.
You cannot refuse an IME — failing to attend can result in suspension of workers' comp benefits. But you can prepare: bring your attorney, know your full injury history, and describe your symptoms completely and accurately. Do not minimize or exaggerate. Every word in that room goes in a report.
Why Gaps in Treatment Hurt Your Case
Insurance companies and defense attorneys look for gaps in your medical treatment. A gap — weeks or months with no medical visits — gets argued as: "If you were really injured, you would have been seeing a doctor. The gap proves you recovered."
Gaps happen for real reasons: no transportation, no health insurance, work demands, fear of missing pay. None of that matters in court without documentation. If you had to pause treatment, make sure your medical records reflect why.
More practically: continue following your doctor's treatment plan. Attend every appointment. Complete recommended physical therapy. Show up for follow-up imaging. Consistent treatment builds a medical record that tells a clear story.
MRI vs. X-Ray — Why It Matters for Your Case
X-rays show bones. MRIs show soft tissue — discs, nerves, ligaments, tendons. The injuries that drive large construction accident settlements are usually soft tissue: herniated or bulging discs, rotator cuff tears, ACL tears, nerve damage.
A fall that looks like "just a bruise" on an X-ray may show significant disc herniation on MRI. If your ER doctor only ordered an X-ray, push for an MRI when you follow up with a specialist. The MRI is usually the document that establishes the extent of your injury.
EMGs (nerve conduction studies) matter too, particularly for back injuries with radiating pain. A positive EMG showing nerve damage is objective, hard to dismiss evidence of a serious injury.
Medical Liens — Who Has a Claim on Your Settlement
Multiple parties may have paid for your medical treatment and have a right to reimbursement from your settlement:
- Workers' comp carrier — reimbursed under WCL § 29 from third-party recovery
- Union health fund — ERISA lien on settlement proceeds
- Medicare/Medicaid — federal law requires repayment if government benefits paid for treatment related to your claim
- Private health insurer — most health insurance policies include subrogation clauses
Your attorney identifies and resolves all liens before you receive your settlement. Settling without addressing liens can result in government agencies or insurers suing you directly. This is handled as part of the settlement process — you don't deal with it alone.
Emergency Room vs. Specialist — The Follow-Up Gap
Emergency rooms stabilize you. They are not set up to fully evaluate orthopedic, neurological, or spinal injuries. The ER may discharge you with instructions to follow up with a specialist — and that follow-up is critical. Seeing an orthopedic surgeon, neurologist, or spine specialist within days of discharge creates the medical record chain that connects your accident to your specific injuries. Without that chain, defense attorneys argue that your injuries could have happened anytime between the accident and whenever you first saw a specialist.
Frequently Asked Questions
My employer says I have to use their workers' comp doctor. Is that true?
For workers' comp benefits, yes — in New York you generally treat with authorized comp providers. But for your personal injury lawsuit, you can and should also see independent specialists. The two tracks are separate.
I have a gap in treatment because I couldn't afford it. Will that destroy my case?
Not necessarily. Attorneys and judges understand financial barriers to care. But the gap needs to be documented and explained. Tell your doctors why you couldn't come in. Your attorney can also address it in the case narrative with supporting context.
What's a Medicare Set-Aside and do I need one?
A Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) is a portion of a settlement set aside to cover future medical expenses that Medicare would otherwise pay. They're required in certain larger workers' comp settlements when the injured worker is on Medicare or will likely become eligible. Your attorney will advise whether one applies to your case.
The IME doctor says I'm fine. Does that end my case?
No. IME reports from insurance-hired doctors are routinely contradicted by your own treating physicians. Courts and juries weigh the treating physician's opinion — based on months of actual care — heavily against a 15-minute IME conducted by a doctor paid by the other side.
Should I tell my doctor I have a lawsuit?
Yes. Be honest with all treating physicians about the accident, your symptoms, and your legal case. Doctors are not adversaries in this process. The medical records they create are the foundation of your damages case — accuracy is what matters.
Ready to Talk to an Attorney?
Free consultation. No fee unless you win.